Read the Progressive Dairy Canada digital edition

The elephant (or beef-cross calf) in the room

Justin Hergenreder for Progressive Dairy Published on 01 June 2020
Beef-cross calf

You likely have heard of or already are implementing strategic breeding in your dairy herd through use of beef genetics, but the elephant (or beef-cross calf) in the room is this: What beef genetics should you be using?

That’s a really good question, and I’m here to help you narrow down the answer. I’ve been in the beef industry all my life. I grew up on a ranch in northern Colorado, earned a degree in animal science from Colorado State University and am a graduate of the Beef Leaders Institute. Today, I work for a cattle genetics cooperative, where I help farmers and ranchers identify the beef genetics that best meet their end goals.



When determining the best beef genetics to use in creating beef-on-dairy cross calves, you should start by identifying the beef genetics that complement dairy breed traits. In other words, consider what beef genetics will provide the most consistent results and ultimately maximize your profits.

The traits to focus on for maximum return include:

Fertility: This is first and foremost. If the semen is not fertile, then nothing else matters. Strategic breeding requires pregnancies, and open cows cost money. If you are not sure how the bulls you are using rate for fertility, ask your genetic provider for bull-fertility rankings.

A blended semen product (semen from multiple bulls in one straw) can be a great way to get a fertility uptick. Blended semen consistently matches or outperforms the highest-fertility bull in the blend with a 1% to 2% increase in conception rates.

Calving ease: It’s been said that a dairy cow should have no problem having a 45-plus-kilogram calf, but why put her through that? While you do not need to use beef bulls with extreme calving ease, at least be conscious of the sire’s calving ease. Remember, for beef sires, a higher calving ease value indicates greater calving ease.


Muscle: Obviously, dairy cattle have not been bred for muscle, so you need to focus on this when choosing sires. Specifically, you need to look at ribeye area (REA). Do you need to use bulls in the top 10% of the breed for REA? No, but you need to put some emphasis on it.

The ultimate goal of selecting a group of sires with more REA is to get a “beef shape” to the ribeye when the animal is harvested and on the rail. One of the easiest ways to tell if a carcass is dairy or beef type is by the shape of the ribeye. A beef-type ribeye is rounder, while a dairy ribeye is longer and more rectangular in shape.

Hide colour: A beef-cross calf with no white colour on its hide colour will help you immensely. There are potential premiums to be earned for delivering black-hided cattle. On the other hand, do not be afraid to make good black-nosed smokes or buckskin-coloured calves as well. I have watched good groups of coloured calves sell just as high as black ones. The key is a hide colour free of white spots.

Quality and price: My grandfather told me, “The most expensive thing you’ll ever buy is a cheap herd bull.” These are words to live by. While it seems simple, remember you are trying to add value to the beef-on-dairy calf, and value-added genetics are not going to be the cheapest. If you step out and pay a little more for sires that are going to create calves buyers seek out, then you can better maximize your return.

Breed: This is a topic that has gone around and around, and I’m sure the discussion will continue for a while. Bottomline, you should use sires that complement the breed of cow you have, and more importantly, use the breed your marketplace is seeking and paying premiums for.

From where I sit, the dairy industry has a lot of great things going for it in terms of the beef-on-dairy cross calf potential. Today’s progressive dairy producers have already created one of the most genetically uniform sets of cows in the world, which is a feat in itself. The next step is to pick the appropriate genetics that fit what the beef industry strives to do every day. These are genetics that create consistent cattle that are trouble-free at birth, grow fast and do it efficiently. Achieving this will create animals that draw buyers to you; when the next person in the supply chain has a great experience with your cattle, they will be back for more, and you will like the premiums they are willing to pay.


Also, take note of other available value-added programs that can help drive your premiums. Look closer at the market and the premiums available for things such as source and age verified, progressive genetics, certified non-hormone-treated cattle and certified natural, just to name a few.

I leave you with this last thought: Please take beef-on-dairy seriously. You have the attention of the cattle industry. There is power in the decisions you make, and you have the opportunity to add a lot of value to your calves. The last thing you want to do is create a bunch of “black Holsteins” that are tall and lack muscle, because once they hit the marketplace, your premiums will be short lived.  end mark

PHOTO: When determining the best beef genetics to use in creating beef-on-dairy cross calves, you should start by identifying the beef genetics that complement dairy breed traits. Photo courtesy of Genex.

Justin Hergenreder
  • Justin Hergenreder

  • Director of Beef Sales
  • Genex
  • Email Justin Hergenreder